Wednesday, November 07, 2007

They Decided To Share

digby, on Hullabaloo, has posted this quote from Chris Matthews, Tweety of the day
"This gender thing is so tricky. Here's my theory. Men voted in the first part of the last century to give women the vote. They had all the votes and decided to share them. They thought, 'they're smart, we're married to them, if momma's not happy nobody's happy' sort of thing."

Let's try telling that to my great-grandmother, the suffragist, shall we? To all of the women who marched and went to jail and were force-fed to break their hunger strikes. To all of the women who heard that only ugly women who couldn't catch a husband would ever want to vote. To all of the women who died before it ever happened. To Abigail Adams, who asked her husband to "remember the women" in the Constitution.*

Even a child's publication, the Scholastic, says on its suffrage page, Women's Suffrage
Woman suffragists often met hostility and sometimes violence.
Yes, yes. Hostility and violence. That sounds to me like deciding to share. Doesn't it to you?

And how about this (also from Scholastic)?
During the Civil War, suffragists shelved their cause temporarily, hoping that at war's end, women as well as emancipated slaves would be enfranchised. After the war Republican party politicians believed enfranchisement of the ex-slaves would be defeated if harnessed to the even more unpopular cause of woman's suffrage. They succeeded in passing the 14th and 15th amendments to the U.S. Constitution, which gave the vote to black men but not to women.
It has always amazed me that men were willing to give the vote to men of other races before they were willing to give it to their own mothers and daughters and sisters. I could understand their not wanting to share power with their wives and even their sisters. But their mothers and daughters? What kind of person doesn't see the humanity of his own parent and child? What does that say about those men?

* Let's remember that there have always been men, like John Stuart Mill and my great-grandfather, who believed in the equality of the sexes. I am not talking about them here. I am talking about the majority of men, who had power and did not gladly give it up.

photo, National Archives of Scotland, Photograph of Janet Arthur, suffragist, 1912, taken from the Home and Health Department criminal case files, NAS ref. HH16/43/2


Uncivil said...

I've always believed in equal opportunity of the sexes and nowdays, I'm deathly scared that the single women of this nation are going to vote Hillary into office!

J at said...

Chris Matthews might also have a theory that the white land owning men decided that all men WERE created equal, and thus decided out of the kindness of their hearts to give the vote to the black men.

Maya's Granny said...

The single women of this nation are the least likely to vote Hillary into office, if you read the polls. The DNC and the media, on the other hand, had decided the nomination was hers before a single vote was cast.

Yes, I think that is his theory about how the black men got the vote.

gawilli said...

"I am talking about the majority of men, who had power and did not gladly give it up."

Sadly this is still the case often times. And worse is my disappointment in the women who have made their own way but can't seem to take care of their own.

MrsGrumpy said...

You beat me to a reply to uncivil, Maya's granny. I am finding out, as a young widow, just how sexist this country, its banks, corporations, the DMV etc... really are. It's as if I am a half person now whenever I contact someone and have to tell them in order to do business. We have so far to go.